Skip to main content

Public Policy and Program Administration

Public Policy

A structured, source-grounded study of public policy: its definitions, nature and scope, the Philippine policy process, the discipline of policy analysis, and the nine models used to explain policy.

Module overview

This module follows the College of Graduate Studies course material on Public Policy. It begins by separating public policy from programme and project management, establishes the working definitions and the classic characterisations, then situates policy in the Philippine setting. The second half develops policy analysis as an applied discipline and works through the nine models of policy analysis, ending with a consolidated comparison and guidance on choosing among them.

Learning objectives

  • Define public policy and distinguish it from programme and project management.
  • Explain the nature, scope, and historical development of the concept of public policy.
  • Describe the Philippine policy process, its stakeholders, and its recurring criticisms.
  • Apply the approaches, information types, and inquiry procedures of policy analysis.
  • Compare the nine models of policy analysis and select an appropriate model for a given question.

Units and lessons

Definitions, nature and scope, the historical and traditional views, and the basic policy process.

Before you begin

What you will learn: The historical perspective associated with Woodrow Wilson, and three traditional definitions.

Why it matters: Each definition widens or narrows who counts as a policy maker and what counts as policy — a question that still shapes policy research.

What you should already know: The general definition and the characterisations from Lessons 2 and 3.

Learning objectives

  • Explain Woodrow Wilson's view of public policy and the politics–administration dichotomy.
  • Compare the definitions of Lasswell and Kaplan, Thomas R. Dye, and Robert Eyestone.
  • Interpret Eyestone's formulation P = F (G, E).

Lesson content

Historical perspective: Woodrow Wilson

Public policy is the laws and regulations which are made by legislative statesmen and implemented by public administration personnel.

— Woodrow Wilson, as cited in Wu Qiyuan, 1985, p. 4
  • This definition is characterized by 'the dichotomy between politics and administration,' which narrows the scope and limits the range of public policy makers.
  • First, public policy includes not only laws and regulations, but also government's plans, instructions, decisions, and other symbolic systems.
  • Secondly, those who participate in the making of public policy include not only statesmen, but also representatives of citizens, experts, and scholars. Especially in the modern era of the 'administrative state' (Waldo, 1984), with the sharp expansion of governmental function and the wide application of administrative judicial rights, executive authorities' participation in making public policy has increased steadily.

Traditional view: Harold Lasswell and Abraham Kaplan (1970)

A projected program of goals, values, and practices.

— Harold Lasswell and Abraham Kaplan, 1970

The module notes that this definition confuses public policy with programs, making the latter seem overly extensive. A program can be public policy, but not all public policies are programs. Public policy also includes instructions, decisions, laws, regulations, and other symbolic systems that government sends out.

Traditional view: Thomas R. Dye (1987)

Public policy is whatever governments choose to do or not to do.

— Thomas R. Dye, 1987
  • Dye focuses not only on government action, but also on government inaction; his definition shows the obvious character of behavioralism and reflects the practical discipline quality of public policy analysis.
  • 'Action' means that government takes measures or uses symbols openly in order to solve some public problem.
  • 'Inaction' means that government does not take measures or express active symbols, abiding by the principle of noninterference.
  • Both are important solutions to public problems.

Traditional view: Robert Eyestone (1971)

In a broad sense, public policy is the relationship between governmental organs and their environment.

— Robert Eyestone, 1971
  • Eyestone is influenced by the science of ecological administration.
  • Public policy is the function of a governmental system and its living environment, namely P = F (G, E), where P refers to public policy, G refers to the governmental system, and E refers to the living environment.
Author(s)DefinitionNoted characteristic
Lasswell and Kaplan (1970)A projected program of goals, values, and practicesConfuses policy with programs; policy is broader
Thomas R. Dye (1987)Whatever governments choose to do or not to doBehavioralist; includes inaction
Robert Eyestone (1971)The relationship between governmental organs and their environmentEcological; expressed as P = F (G, E)
Traditional views compared

Source material: Public Policy module, 'Historical Perspective' and 'Traditional Views'. Wilson reference link cited in the module: onlinedegrees.kent.edu — father of public administration.

Key concepts

  • Wilson's view rests on the dichotomy between politics and administration, narrowing who makes policy.
  • Policy includes plans, instructions, decisions and other symbolic systems, not only laws and regulations.
  • Lasswell and Kaplan define policy as a projected program of goals, values, and practices.
  • Dye includes both action and inaction.
  • Eyestone expresses policy as P = F (G, E).

Terms to know

Politics–administration dichotomy
The separation implied in Wilson's definition, where legislative statesmen make laws and administration personnel implement them, which narrows the range of policy makers.
In plain terms: The idea that politicians decide and administrators only carry out.
Behavioralism
The character the module attributes to Dye's definition because it focuses on what government actually does or does not do.
In plain terms: Judging policy by observed government behaviour, not stated intentions.
P = F (G, E)
Eyestone's formulation: public policy is a function of the governmental system (G) and its living environment (E).
In plain terms: Policy is the result of government and its surroundings interacting.
Administrative state
The modern era described by Waldo (1984) in which governmental function has expanded sharply and executive participation in policy making has increased steadily.
In plain terms: A government where agencies, not only legislators, shape policy.
Put simply

Each author draws the boundary of 'policy' in a different place. Wilson draws it narrowly around laws and lawmakers. Lasswell and Kaplan draw it around programmes. Dye widens it to include doing nothing. Eyestone widens it further to the whole relationship between government and its environment.

Seat work

Answer the application questions. Your work is saved on this device.

Knowledge check

4 questions. Answer all of them, then check your work to see feedback for each item.

1.Whose definition states that public policy is 'whatever governments choose to do or not to do'?

2.In Eyestone's formulation P = F (G, E), what does E represent?

3.The module accepts Lasswell and Kaplan's definition without criticism.

4.Explain what the module means by the 'dichotomy between politics and administration'.

Answer every question to continue.

Lesson summary

  • Wilson's historical view ties policy to laws made by statesmen and implemented by administrators.
  • The module rejects that narrow scope: policy also includes plans, instructions, decisions and symbolic systems.
  • Policy makers include citizens' representatives, experts and scholars, especially in the administrative state.
  • Lasswell and Kaplan, Dye, and Eyestone each widen the definition in a different direction.
  • Dye's inclusion of inaction and Eyestone's P = F (G, E) are the two most frequently cited widenings.
My notes

Notes are saved on this device for the demo.

No notes on this lesson yet.